The narcissistic history of photography and possibilities for breaking out of a single story

The narcissistic history of photography and possibilities for breaking out of a single story
What does it mean to live in a world surrounded by photographic images and not feel part of them? Even though, at first, we may not have the answer to this question, we know that it resonates in the lives of many people. Unfortunately, we still live in a world where the images produced do not speak to everyone. The history of photography is an example of this. Despite filling its pages with countless images, few of them are directed at bodies and stories outside of a Eurocentric model of life and existence, causing discomfort for a large portion of humanity.
The search for recognition in images is a common theme in studies dedicated to photography. Many authors have written about this, such as Rosalind Krauss, Susan Sontag, Roland Barthes, and others. One of the narratives used to understand this search is the Greek myth of Narcissus, as mentioned by Krauss in her book The Photographic. The story of the young man who, condemned to love his own reflection, becomes incapable of engaging with or falling in love with another person, illustrates how the history of Western photography was constructed. The desire for one’s own image is inherent in the development of human individuality, and knowing this, it’s natural that we seek out our visual constructions in the world.

Poster promoting the exhibition “Fotopreta | Norte Nordeste”, by the Afrotometria Collective. All images used in this article are courtesy of the Afrotometria Collective.
The search for a self in an image is legitimate. However, it is essential to constantly pay attention to ensure that this occurs in balance, valuing both the gaze towards oneself and towards others. And when this process doesn’t happen this way, it creates a problem for everyone. If I see myself too much, I construct a narrative centered on the self, excluding others. If I do not see myself, I do not recognize myself, and therefore do not belong. It seems that the so-called history of photography is at this point, in the imbalance of presences.
The artist, psychologist, and activist Grada Kilomba, in her book Memórias da Plantação (Memories of the Plantation), analyzes the remnants of colonialism in racial and social structures, observing how this affects our imagination and societal model. For Kilomba, the plot of Narcissus' life helps us understand the process of constructing racial identities and whiteness. She notes that whiteness, like Narcissus, is surrounded by actions directed towards itself, reinforcing exclusions and the dehumanization of non-white bodies.
The history of photography, to some extent, normalizes the presence of white and heteronormative bodies as universal, creating a sense of non-place or non-belonging for others. It’s not by chance that the well-known Shirley cards, used to "standardize" skin tones during the photographic printing process and widely used in analog photographic studios in the past century, only included non-white people as part of the studies from the 1990s onwards.

Sergio Fernandes "Silêncio"

Georgia Niara "Célula de água"

Fernando Solidade "Bloco Afro é Di Santo", 2020
Grada Kilomba observes that whiteness, like Narcissus, is surrounded by actions directed toward itself, reinforcing exclusions and the dehumanization of non-white bodies.
Knowing this, the question that remains is: how do we rewrite the history of photography? How can we break out of this vicious cycle of colonialities and exclusions? One attempt to answer this question is the book Reflections in Black: A History of Black Photographers, 1840 to the Present by researcher Deborah Willis. The publication offers us another history of photography, written and represented by Black people. In Brazil, another project also seeks to rewrite the history of photography through Black authorship, aiming to construct new visualities, redefine technical and relational processes, and create a collective Black writing for photography.
These are not the only projects dedicated to this rewriting, and it is essential that we access them. If the history of photography is a history of narcissists, may it become a history of multiple narcissists and existences. May we confront the mechanisms of the representation game, providing mirrors for all.